Twelve essential facts about the experience of hearing voices




Page updated 21/10/2007



1. Voice hearing is often seen as a prime symptom of psychosis (American Psychiatric Association 1994). Hearing voices (auditory hallucinations) is considered a first rank symptom of the specific psychosis of schizophrenia (Schneider, 1959). There are three main psychiatric categories of patients that hear voices; schizophrenia (around 50%); affective psychosis (around 25%) and dissociative disorders (around 80%) (Honig et al., 1998).




2. However, hearing voices in itself is not a symptom of an illness, but is apparent in 2 - 4 % of the population, some research gives higher estimates and even more people (about 8%) have so called "peculiar personal convictions", that are sometimes called "delusions", and do so without being ill. Many people who hear voices find them helpful or benevolent (Romme & Escher, 1993). In a large study of 15,000 people it was found that there was a prevalence of 2.3% who had heard voices frequently and this contrasts with the 1% prevalence of schizophrenia (Tien, 1991).




3. Whilst one in three people who hear voices become a psychiatric patient - two in three people can cope well and are in no need of psychiatric care. No diagnosis can be given because these 2 out of 3 people who hear voices are quite healthy and function well. It is very significant that in our society there are more people who hear voices who have never been psychiatric patients than there are people who hear voices and become psychiatric patients. (Romme & Escher, 2001)




4. Brain imaging has confirmed that voice hearers do experience a sound as if there were a real person talking to them (Shergill, Brammer, Williams, Murray, & McGuire, 2000).




5. In a study by Honig and others (1998), of the differences between non-patient and patients hearing voices, it was not in form but content. In other words the non-patients heard voices both inside and outside their head as did the patients but either the content was positive or the hearer had a positive view of the voice and felt in control of it. By contrast the patient group were more frightened of the voices and the voices were more critical (malevolent) and they felt less control over them (Honig et al, 1998).




6. Psychiatry in our western culture unjustly identifies hearing voices with schizophrenia. Going to a psychiatrist with hearing voices gives you an 80% chance of getting a diagnosis of schizophrenia (Romme & Escher 2001).




7. Conventional approaches in psychiatry to the problem of voice hearing have been to ignore the meaning of the experience for the voice hearer and concentrate on removing the symptoms (audio hallucinations) by the use of physical means such as medication (Romme & Escher, 1989). Although antipsychotic medication is helpful to some sufferers of psychosis (Fleischhaker, 2002), there is a significant proportion (30 per cent) that still experience the ‘symptoms’ such as hearing voices despite very high doses of injected antipsychotic (Curson, Barnes, Bamber, & Weral, 1985).




8. Further anti-psychotic medication prevents the emotional processing and therefore healing, of the meaning of the voices (Romme & Escher, 2000).




9. Traditional practice in behavioural psychology concentrated on either distracting the patient or ignoring references by the patient to the voice hearing experience, with the hope that the patient would concentrate on ‘real’ experiences, which would then be positively reinforced (the assumption being that the voice hearing was a delusional belief). The effect of this approach is to discourage the discussion about the voice hearing experience but without eradicating it (P.D.J. Chadwick, Birchwood, & Trower, 1996).




10. In research concerning people who hear voices it was found that 77% of the people diagnosed with schizophrenia the hearing of voices was related to traumatic experiences. These traumatic experiences varied from being sexually abused, physically abused, being extremely belittled over long periods from young age, being neglected during long periods as a youngster, being very aggressively treated in marriage, not being able to accept ones sexual identity, etc (Romme & Escher 2006)




11, Hearing voices in itself is not related to the illness of schizophrenia. In population research only 16% of the whole group of voice hearers can be diagnosed with schizophrenia. (Romme & Escher 2001)




12. The prognosis of hearing voices is more positive than generally is perceived. In Sandra Escher's research with children hearing voices she followed 82 children over a period of four years. In that period 64% of the children’s voices disappeared congruently with learning to cope with emotions and becoming less stressed. In children with whom the voices were psychiatrised and made a part of an illness and not given proper attention, voices did not vanish, but became worse, the development of those children was delayed. (Romme & Escher 2006)






Comments

Leave a response

  1. HolleyNovember 14, 2007 @ 02:32 AM
    I hear voices when I just look at my medication because I know it isn't the all-true answer and that it causes an unjust amount of bodily problems. Do you have talk therapy on your site?
  2. AlisonNovember 26, 2007 @ 02:23 AM
    I have heard voices since I was 41 years old (10 years ago). Sometimes they were clear, sometimes faint. They have given me very helpful guidance and although I have been reluctant to 'connect' (afraid I had a mental illness), I cope much better when I am in contact with the voices. I have seen two psychologists about my voices, and both have encouraged me to stay connected. They believe my voices benefit me and I seem a lot more confident and at peace with myself when I am in regular contact. I have kept journals of the conversations I have had with my voices and am often surprised by the knowledge they have about me, other people, and most things, although they sometimes answer with "You are not to know." Your website has been reassuring and I would like to thank you for the information. Regards Alison.
  3. ToniJanuary 14, 2008 @ 03:03 AM
    I just started hearing this voice.I have heard it about 6 times at first all it did was say my name,then one time it told me to stop yelling at the dogs,the last time I heard the voice it ask me if I was all right,I am alone most of the time it has happened,it's a male voice and when it happens I don't feel any fear of the voice.Hopefully I can find some answers on your website.Thank-you Toni
  4. OrcaLoverJanuary 29, 2008 @ 12:06 AM
    I'm 29/M and I have never heard voices. I think it sounds very fascinating that you can hear a 'real' voice in your head like somebody else is talking to you. It would scare the living hell out of me if it happened to myself though. However there must be some way that you can use it in a positive manner. I wonder if the voices could be used to access your subconscious mind like a kind of super intuition? In ancient times you'd probably have been shamans or maybe the Oracle of Delhi LOL Seriously, I think lots of people would like to communicate with these voices in a spiritual setting. What do the voices say? Can they give you information beyond your knowledge?
  5. PeggyFebruary 11, 2008 @ 08:44 PM
    Hi All, My boyfriend says he hears voices and sees figures. Sometimes the figures/voices take on an actor's/famous person's persona such as The Hulk, the Dali Lama, etc. Sometimes I find him looking up into the air "taking to them". He seems quite rational and is very helpful and affectionate. In my concern about this, I found a very interesting website and both he and I are going for the healing/miracles to be found at www.energeticmatrix.com. The inventor, Stephen Lewis, has several radio broadcasts at www.talkshoe.com (then search on EMC2 and listen to Conner's Corner) that say that some people who were cleared of their diabetes cleared the voices in their heads. Diabetes runs in his family and his father died of diabetes complications. I'll let you know if this website's AIM program works for this. In the meantime, I hope this helps someone.
  6. MicheleFebruary 18, 2008 @ 02:33 AM
    My son hears voices (or a voice). He's only 10. He first told me about this when he was 8. I fell apart! He saw a psychologist for a few weeks, and she gave him exercises to work on. I found an article by Romme & Escher on the web re, accepting voices. I helped him 'become the boss'. They went away for a while. 6 months later they came back briefly when he was really anxious about a swim carnival. Then nothing again. It's been twelve months exactly and they are back. Surprise surprise so is the swim carnival!! He is having trouble controlling them this time because he is out of practise. He can never understand what is being said. He says it's like someone speaking so fast that you can't pick out any words. He said they may as well be speaking chinese. Sometimes words are just jumbled around as well. He has no other symptoms but when the voice is here, he makes a lot more noise to distract himself, ie humming, singing. The problem is when he is in class because he has to be quite. I still freak out - I don't know what is coming in the future, but I hope that with our support he will find a way to cope, come what may. The hardest part is keeping it a secret, I desperately want to talk to someone, but I can't do that to him. It still feels like something really wrong and I wish it was a more open subject. Maybe in time!
  7. erskineMarch 06, 2008 @ 04:36 AM
    I have been experiencing hearing voices since birth. I just wonder if anyone else has to deal with stupid voices. All of the voices aren't stupid but some of them are just morons.
  8. lauraMarch 17, 2008 @ 03:45 AM
    my 8 year old great niece that i am raising has been hearing voices in her head for 4 years now and they are telling her to do bad things like hurt people and animals i have had her in the hospital twice now and they do not stop or go away she is a twin and they both have fetal alcohol syndrome and attachment disorder and adhd and the list with joy justs keeps growing and it is worring me very much
  9. DonnieMarch 17, 2008 @ 11:35 PM
    my voices say thay are little brother of the federal governent and i have heard Dr j vernen magee bible sckaller say in a bible study that big brother was the right hand of satan hes een gone for about 20 years so he probably havent heard of little brother but its probably the right hand of satan
  10. beckyMarch 18, 2008 @ 11:52 PM
    my 24-year-old daughter hears spirit voices all the time. Some are benevolent, some are threatening. She claims to want to be rid of them, but she is reluctant to take the medication because she thinks it will "open the doorway" to more spirits instead of inhibiting them. She does peculiar rituals to rid herself of a particularly nasty spirit, rituals she learned from the Wiccan store in her town. I think she's halucinating. She thinks she's got a psychic gift.
  11. MarcellaApril 28, 2008 @ 10:54 PM
    I truly believe in #8 and #10 from the above list. I used Meth for six years. During that time I started hearing voices. I was also in such a bad relationship, that now I believe that also contributed to my onset of hearing voices. Although my drug addiction has been over for almost a year and the voices have almost gone away, a couple weeks ago some thing triggered the hell that I was going through when my voices started and they started to return. I joined a voice hears group on yahoo and I should be starting therapy in a couple of weeks. The group has helped again with the calming of my voices and I think therapy will help me overcome the problems of this past bad relationship. I don't take meds because of side effects and recent suicide attempts. I also think they are just a band-aide not the real cure. They may make life a lot easier for some, but I feel they take all your emotion and your fight to find a solution. I'm not downing the fact that anyone takes meds, for some it is way to cope. And my first break in my voices were while takeing meds. I really thought it was going to be away of life for me. I actully welcomed it. And I know it is hard to find a doctor you can trust. I'm still on that quest. Maybe it's because I have had such a break in my voices that feel this way about meds meds(#8). But to you all it's something to really think about. I wish to all voice hearers who suffer that they can find a solution and hopefully come of meds. It has been a hard fight but I think it has been worth it. Take care and don't give up!
  12. MarcellaApril 28, 2008 @ 11:10 PM
    I also wanted to add that one therapist (whom I liked and trusted) told me that since I was a drug user it would be hard to tell if my voices were caused by something else. PTSD or SZ... Does anyone know if there has been any studies on this? It has been very hard on me to want to talk to my next doctor about my drug addiction. But feel I should leave nothing out for my recover to work.
  13. KristiApril 30, 2008 @ 05:56 PM
    To Michele from Feb 18, 2008: It sounds like my own son has a very similar voice experience to your son's. My son is 18 and he first told me about his voice when he was 6. Like you, I freaked out. I asked him many questions about it. I remember telling myself that schizophrenia doesn't usually start until late teens or early twenties (that is all I could think of to explain it, I'm afraid). It stopped for a few years, but it has been back for about a year now. He describes it exactly the way your son does, he can't understand what it says because it talks too fast or the words are just unintelligible. I haven't sought professional help for him because I was worried they would just put him on meds and not know what was really going on. Is there anyone else out there who has had this kind of voice - one that you can't understand? Is there any way to "connect" with such a thing? I am struggling to understand this and would appreciate any advice.
Comment

...have your say